Millais’s Good Samaritan (one of the illustrations by Millais for work other than Trollope’s I showed and discussed)
Dear friends and readers,
I am again very gratified to be able to say I gave a online talk to the London Trollope Society on-line reading group (a fourth), and it went over very well. People were interested by the pictures themselves (remember Alice in Wonderland on pictures and conversations in books), and asked questions about book illustrations in Trollope and other Victorian writers (“did people really like these?”). I was asked if I’d do another, and came up with two (!).
I’m not sure how much I’ve sufficiently emphasized the motive for all four has been more than partly personal. I just love Cornish films, film adaptations, and “Malachi’s Cove” overturns so many stereotypes about Trollope’s fiction that bother me; Dr Thorne was really the book that started me on this long journey into reading, writing, sharing something of what I’ve known and felt for Trollope (original title: On rereading Dr Thorne a half century later); I am a strong defender of Josiah Crawley, one of the many solitary semi-outcasts of Trollope’s fiction,
Frances Arthur Fraser’s “Dogged as Does It” (for a later edition of The Last Chronicle of Barset) — one of the illustrations I discuss in my talk
and was felt so moved by Lindsay Duncan’s performance as an updated version of Crawley’s long-suffering wife (The Modernity of the Last Chronicle of Barset — and The Rector’s Wife).
Lindsay Duncan as Anna Bouverie
“The Original Illustrations to Trollope’s Novels” have been dear to my heart since I wrote my long chapter in my book, Trollope on the Net on them (1999). I spent long weeks and hours in the rare book room of the Library of Congress starting at few hundred of them, and was chuffed when in Mark Turner’s review of my book he singled out this chapter to discuss as peculiarly excellent. As you know if you visit this blog with any regularity, I love pictures, studying art history (and on my other blog, women artists), and writing about film adaptations (moving pictures). And the only chance I’ve had since my book to share any of the visual art and realization in the original illustrations was in paper I gave at a Sharp-l conference some years ago now I called “Mapping Trollope; or, Georgraphies of Power. When we were a larger group on my Trollope and his Contemporaries list, we’d have people describe the original illustrations as part of what we volunteered to do — especially when the pictures are good, people showed curiosity and were comfortable talking about what they see — in the way people are about movies.
So without further ado, here it is:
Here’s the transcript on the Trollope Society website. And the page itself
Last, a brief synopsis: I present why Trollope said he so valued Millais’s pictures, described some of the obstacles in the way of understanding or appreciating them and the other central style of illustrations in the period (idyllic naturalistic versus caricature emblematic), then talk about the nature of Millais’s basic thrust (expressionistic), how far more daring than one realizes, and stunning some of them are outside the characteristic novels of the era (e.g., defying taboos) and finally describe and discuss the series on Lady Mason: as a group they create sympathy for her and reveal the cost to her of attempting to provide her son with a gentleman’s education and income, and herself with the respect and dignity and space for herself of a lady’s life: a life alone, a life apart. Mary Lady Mason is another of Trollope’s solitaries inside a fiction with radical implications about society and the nature of justice and law in court cases.
“Farewell:” the penultimate Millais illustration for Orley Farm: there is no literal basis for this scene in the novel
Ellen
The coming two will be: “Barsetshire in Pictures:” on Millais’s illustrations for The Small House at Allington and George Housman Thomas’s for The Last Chronicle of Barset and Alan Plater’s 1983 BBC Barchester Chronicles (June 6th). “On seeing Divergent Pallisers: ” On Phiz’s and Miss E. Taylor’s illustrations for Can You Forgive Her? and the first five episode of Simon Raven’s 1974 BBC The Pallisers (November 28th).
I placed it on academia. edu also
https://www.academia.edu/76173723/Trollope_Millais_and_Orley_Farm_EMoody
Thank you so much for sharing this. I have thoroughly enjoyed both your “Mapping….” article and this discussion of the Orley Farm illustrations. Definitely time for me to return to the novels after a long absence.
MIchele Raynor: “Many thanks for this, Ellen Moody. This was my first ever Trollope and l have the edition with the wonderful illustrations.”
Kenneth Jones: “Thank you. I usually attend the Monday Zoom meeting but couldn’t this week. I’m looking forward to seeing this! Your presentations are always so interesting.”
Millais and expressionism:
So he did this ca. 70 years before it was popular
[I am thinking of Abstract Expressionism here – 1910-25 was its peak].
And the Lady Mason series.
The TV shows are 40 and 50 years away from the current moment.